Home What's New Message Board
BigPumpkins.com
Select Destination Site Search

Message Board

 
General Discussion

Subject:  To weed or not to weed

General Discussion      Return to Board List

From

Location

Message

Date Posted

Smallmouth

Upa Creek, MO

I have been out of the loop for a bit and was wondering what the consensus these days is for weeding?

Eliminate weeds, and risk compromising root structure on a well established plant?

Leave weeds, and risk them absorbing nutrients and reducing potential size of the AGs?

Thanks!

4/18/2025 7:24:09 PM

pumpkinpal2

Syracuse, NY

Just imagine if anyone spent the money on merely walking boards to cover as much of the growing area as possible.
No weeds THERE and what weeds would grow would supplement the growing environment of the vines and such, as long as the weeds themselves were not of a variety that would become taller (thereby using up said nutrients) than the AG leaves themselves. Minimal weeding, practically NO soil compaction and so on. My dream. Don't wake me up, lol. eg

[Last edit: 04/19/25 3:46:25 AM]

4/19/2025 3:45:56 AM

Vineman

Eugene,OR

I think weeding is essential…it is just part of the deal.

4/19/2025 9:49:09 AM

Dalton

Ironton, ohio

I weed the best I can as the plant grows out, once it fills its allotted area and secondaries press up against the fence it becomes tough to get into the older areas of plant to weed. Weeding is on the list of things I hope to be better at this season, only time will tell if it leads to heavier fruit. Good luck everyone!

4/19/2025 11:50:54 AM

Andy W

Western NY

You don't need a weed free garden to grow a good one:

http://www.bigpumpkins.com/Diary/DiaryViewOne.asp?eid=341605

But a weed free garden would have helped to make it less of a safe haven for mice.

4/19/2025 2:49:36 PM

Vineman

Eugene,OR

If you want to have good airflow to help reduce pressure from powdery mildew, weeding is important.

4/19/2025 5:04:50 PM

Little Ketchup

Grittyville, WA

I have not read any studies where weeds enhanced the growth of the target crop. There are ways to suppress or kill weeds without damaging the pumpkin roots? But yeah the weeding should be done in a non-damaging way. My favorite way to get rid of weeds is to "bury them alive". But, this wont work with some of them.

[Last edit: 04/20/25 12:45:58 AM]

4/20/2025 12:37:43 AM

Pumpking

Germany

Yep, this "bury them alive" thing is good, it´s one of the first things I do every year. In some of my diary entries you can have a glance under the canopy, hardly any weeds, and that comes from a combination of strategies rather than from weeding between the pumpkin plants.
- In February or early March, the first "weed problems" may arise when things such as chickweed goes to flower (and will set seeds a couple days or weeks later). So, when I see that stuff develop the first flowers, it´s the time to bury it alive. No seeds, no weeds...from that source.
- Thereafter, I sow a sping cover crop that grows quick and dense, something that still allows for weed seeds to germinate, but then the weed seedlings can´t grow because of lack of light. One of the reasons why I´m growing phacelia every spring. I let it grow until it is close to going to seed, but then I remove it (rather than having fun with phacelia seedlings throughout the year).
- The bare soil (where the phacelia had been growing, and the other parts of the patch during the time before the AG plants cover that area) receives some occasional rain and sunshine, so some (well, many) of the weed seeds in the soil will want to start...and every couple of days I treat that surface with a plow rake...in a rather shallow manner. It preserves the soil structure and the moisture therein, but it disturbs and eventually kills the weed seedlings.

As soon as the AG plants reach those parts of the patch, they shade it, and the density of weed seedlings popping up is already pretty low.

There are some weeds (such as the Chenopodium album) that I´m still after...as soon as I see those plants grow, I´ll try to pull them as long as I can reach them easily.

4/20/2025 3:05:40 AM

big moon

Bethlehem CT

I think it is very important to have the weeds under control. You want good airflow, and lots of sunlight. If the weeds get too out of control they will limit your ability to properly spray your plant and it will also limit the amount of sun that can get to the leaves. Some weed species are far more harmful than others. (pigweed and Lambsquarters can get to six feet tall in my garden) If the weeds are taller than the pumpkin leaves you are in trouble.

4/20/2025 8:05:03 AM

Steve's Garage

New Castle, Indiana

If you don't control weeds they will often take over the patch faster than the pumpkin plants will and end up using some of that soil amendment you put down. This year I put down Preen to hopefully prevent the crabgrass from germinating because I know there's a lot of it out there. Then I go around with a hoop hoe for what does come up. Yes, some grasses may try to come up under the canopy and I pull those out as I'm able but I can't get to all of it without risking damage to the vines.

4/20/2025 2:34:26 PM

Smallmouth

Upa Creek, MO

Thanks, all opinions appreciated and considered.

4/21/2025 4:06:12 PM

Total Posts: 11 Current Server Time: 5/2/2025 5:04:30 PM
 
General Discussion      Return to Board List
  Note: Sign In is required to reply or post messages.
 
Top of Page

Questions or comments? Send mail to Ken AT bigpumpkins.com.
Copyright © 1999-2025 BigPumpkins.com. All rights reserved.